You Scream, I Scream, We all Scream for (Soft Serve) Ice Cream

Summer is soft serve ice cream. Hot, long days beg for the light, airy texture that regular ice cream just can’t deliver. I mean, I’m never going to turn my nose up at a banana chip cone from Aglamesis or mint chip from, well, anywhere, but soft serve is special. This is a relationship born in childhood.   Most of my summers were spent in the beautiful Northwoods of Wisconsin.  Fishing, swimming, and frequent trips to the Dairy Maid in Land O Lakes, Wisconsin.  Our home was a 20-minute drive from town and going to town was a treat.  The Dairy Maid (still there) was the place we loved taking family and friends.   All these years later, I would still argue that it’s THE ice cream to scream about!  But, is it really the ice cream that’s so wonderful or is it the memories?  I think it’s both.  Summer is my Aunt Ginny and her small turtle sundae.  It’s my mom and her mint milkshake.  It’s my own chocolate ice cream cone dipped in cherry.  Yes.  Summer is precious; summer is soft.

When I dip you dip we dip!

So, since it’s summertime and I pretty much have never met an ice cream cone I didn’t like, my husband, based on the suggestions of readers, drove me around the greater Cincinnati area in search of the best soft serve.  What did I learn?  People are passionate about their favorite whippy dips and dairy stands.  But, does all soft serve taste the same?  Does it matter where the goodness comes from?  Yes!  Yes, my friends; it does.

Here are a few highlights from the places we visited:

  • Zip Dip in Cheviot- Homemade orange soft serve sherbet = creamsicle on a cone.  Cute seating area.  Well-landscaped.
  • Tucker’s Whippy Dip in Mason- Blackberry soft serve. Enough said.
  • Putz’s in Mt. Airy- Strong chocolate shake! Community gathering place.  Best straight up vanilla soft serve. Family operated since its opening in the 1930’s.
  • Dairy Whip in Loveland- Cute kid’s options.  Tons of sundae choices. Blueberry soft serve mimics Kings Island.
  • Trackside Treats in Anna, OH- Throwing this one in for my hometown family and friends.  Nice patio seating.  Super friendly service.  Easy drive-thru.  Offers rotating flavors of Dole Whip (nondairy and super fruity).
  • Dairy Corner in Newtown- Killer blue raspberry dip here!  Best yet (and I love my dips). If you don’t know what dip is, think magic shell.  It hardens against the cold ice cream; beware though because the ice cream melts fast, but it’s worth it!  This soft serve is lighter, icier, and thinner which I like!
  • Creamy Whip in Mt. Washington- Baked goods available.  Super duper creamy texture.  Loads of toppings! Generous ice cream portions.  Best cherry dip.  Friendly service. Indoor and outdoor seating. This one feels like an ice cream parlor!

Zip Dip.

This kind of line is common at Putz’s.

Ummm. Just look at these treats for kids at the Dairy Whip in Loveland.

This pic of my parents is precious! Enjoying soft serve from Trackside in Anna, OH.

Blue raspberry dip from the Dairy Corner in Newtown!

A friend favorite: a blizzard made with real cake from the Creamy Whip in Mt. Washington.

Now, the awards for best tasty treat go to:

  • Flubs in Hamilton- In addition to great soft serve, Flubs has soft serve Italian ice (dairy free) and homemade sherbet soft serve.  When we visited, the sherbet flavors were orange, blue raspberry, and fresh nectarine.  We tasted each and they were refreshing and delicious, but man that fresh nectarine was special!  My husband got chocolate soft serve topped with freshly made brownies (still warm) and a cherry on top.  It was the farthest drive, but this no-frills (no real sign even) Dairi-ette definitely stands out.
  • The Cone in West Chester- First of all, the ice cream stand is shaped like a cone!  Bonus points right there.  The cone has a huge variety of dips including toasted coconut, cake batter, peanut butter, and cotton candy.  It also has a game room, covered seating, and a quirky drive-thru.  If you don’t want regular soft-serve, the cone offers homemade sherbets and Italian ices (all soft serve).  The menu is huge . . . begging for another visit.

Fresh nectarine from the Flubbs.

Chocolate soft serve topped with freshly baked brownies from Flubbs.

My sister loved this strawberry and orange sherbet from The Cone.

Key lime and blue raspberry Italian ice from The Cone

I know I celebrate local places and don’t usually write about chains, but I have another strong memory associated with soft serve ice cream. This one is equally as sweet.  I remember helping my dad make homemade ice cream for family dinners and fish fries.  We brought out the wooden bucket, cranked it by hand, and my dad, sitting in his lawn chair, would dish it out by the bowl full.  He always topped that sweet, icy, homemade goodness with “chocolate dope”.  It’s because of this memory that I must mention Chick-fil-A’s ice dream cone; it’s the vanilla ice cream that takes me back home to those people and those meals that I miss so much!  

Ice dream from Chick-fil-A.

I know summer does not own ice cream, but it’s the time to celebrate our favorite little ice cream stands.  To make memories.  To gather.  To treat ourselves.  To stay up late.   To feel like a kid even if we aren’t so little anymore.  I’d love to hear more about your most coveted places and favorite treats!

Tip: Take cash; many free standing soft serve shops are cash only!

GO THERE (all the soft serve places)! TRY THAT (soft serve, sherbet, dips)! 

The Cone Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato


Wildflower Cafe and Coffee House

Located in Mason, in a quaint, yellow farm house, the Wildflower Cafe and Coffee House serves up an ever-changing menu inspired by the seasons.  The food at this family owned and operated restaurant is fresh, farm-to-table, locally harvested, and hearty.  The kitchen might be tiny, but the bites are big!

Parking in back.

No secret where the ingredients come from!

We stumbled upon Wildflower Cafe a few years ago after reading an article about best burgers in Cincinnati.  Just so happens, we really were in search of the best burger in the city! We’d been to several places on this list, but never to Wildflower.  When we decided to check it out we were a little skeptical because it’s one of those all grass-fed beef deals, not there’s anything wrong with that, it’s just not necessarily what I think of in a big, juicy burger.  But, we fell in love with the atmosphere and I have to say the burgers are freakin’ delicious. Thick, juicy, cooked medium, never dry and not too greasy.  It’s an all around strong burger.

We recently went back with a group of friends.  Due to the size of our party, we had the top floor of this former residential farm house to ourselves; it was just big enough.  Remember, this is a house converted into a restaurant.  It’s the best of both worlds.  Home + Comfort Food.  It’s just a place where it feels good to eat!  I couldn’t describe it better than my friend Amanda.  She said, ” I am obsessed with the decor.  It reminds me of a breezy, beautifully lighted, Southern charm of a place in Savannah.  And I’d go back expressly to try that outdoor seating area.” Between all of us in our group, we ordered many different dishes; all positive reviews!

If I were forced, hands tied behind my back, to name the standout dishes, I’d go with:

  • Simon and Garfunkel Chicken Pot Pie-  “Dogwood Farm” pasture-raised chicken + Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme + local cream + summer vegetables + buttery puff pastry crust
  • “Grassland Graze” Beef Burger-  local grass-fed beef + 16 Bricks sesame bun + “everything” relish + local heirloom tomato + summer greens- Served with a simple salad & your choice of: Uncle Ron’s cheese sauce, Goat cheese, or Smoked Blue
  • Truffled Summer Gnocchi-  housemade gnocchi + local heirloom tomato + local veggies + nuts + summer herbs + shaved onion + smoked blue cheese + balsamic glaze
  • Smoked Grass-fed Ribeye-  12 oz boneless cut + 10 hour smoked + chive bearnaise + whipped potatoes
  • Lobster Mac & Cheese-  sauteed lobster tail+ Uncle Ron’s cheese sauce + local greens + local heirloom tomato + goat cheese + double smoked bacon


Chicken Pot Pie



Lobster Mac & Cheese

1) I think I just rattled off most of the menu and 2) we dug into that burger soooo quickly that I don’t have a pic (#bloggerfail)!  Sorry friends.  But, I will leave you with dessert!  No great dinner is complete without it.  We capped this night of friendship and food by sharing the Chocolate Peanut Butter Napoleon (chocolate ganache + peanut butter whip) and Grandma Hudson’s Bread Pudding (with bourbon butter). While I might have had dreams of bathing in that peanut butter whip, everyone raved about the bread pudding.  By the way, notice that beautiful cup of La Terza coffee in the background of the pic below?  Who said coffee is only a morning drink . . . lies! Nothing much better than coffee and dessert!

Chocolate Peanut Butter Napoleon

Bread Pudding

Check out more of Wildflower Cafe’s sweet story here! And remember, make a reservation!  Space is limited.

GO THERE (Wildflower Cafe)!  TRY THAT (Ribeye, Burger, Gnocchi, Pot Pie)! 

Wildflower Cafe Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato